← All results

Case study 02 · National hotel chain

ROAS: from 0 to 12x.

A national hotel chain with 18 locations relied almost entirely on online travel agencies (OTAs), like Expedia and Hotels.com, for its bookings. It had just started building its own marketing, and the new website a previous team launched was broken. McCarter Collective came in to clean it up and build a direct booking program from scratch.

Landon McCarter
18 locations across the West and Southwest.
18
locations
12x
peak ROAS (return on ad spend)
7 months
from launch to scale

The cleanup

The website was a train wreck.

The new site was the front end for the booking engine, but nothing underneath it worked. Analytics wasn't connected. There was no Google Search Console. URLs were mapped wrong and there was no SEO. We installed the right tools, ran a full audit, fixed the URL mapping and errors, and got the whole digital footprint back in good standing.

Before
Analytics
Search Console
URL mapping
SEO
Site health
After
Analytics
Search Console
URL mapping
SEO
Site health

You can't fix what you can't measure.
So we started with measurement.

The storefront

The real storefront is on Google Maps.

For hotels, each location's Google Business Profile matters as much as the website, often more. It's where travelers find, compare and call, and it's how AI assistants decide which hotel to recommend.

Our edge is alignment: the website and every location's profile working together, plus profile work most marketers don't know exists, or don't know why it matters or how to execute it.

We audited and rebuilt all 18 profiles. That drives maps rankings for the searches that matter, and maps rankings drive calls, website traffic and direct bookings. The specifics are what we walk through on a strategy call. I will tell you specifically what tricks matter most.

Website
aligned
Google Business Profile
Maps rankings
AI recommendations
Calls
Direct bookings
18 of 18
profiles audited and aligned

Two ways to start: talk it through, or let me look at your site first.

Book a Strategy Call Get my Google Maps Loom review

The leak

The data found the leak.

We built and launched a Google Hotel Ads program, the ad format built specifically for hotels. ROAS sat around 2.5x and leadership wanted to know why. Because the ads were live and tracked, the answer showed up in the data: OTAs (Online Travel Agencies) were advertising the hotels on Google at lower rates than the hotels' own direct rate. That breaks rate parity, the contract rule that OTAs can't undercut the hotel's price. Why would a traveler book direct when a cheaper price sits right next to it?

Hotel prices · Tonight
Before
Official site$129
OTA A$109
OTA B$99
OTAs undercutting the hotel's own rate
Hotel prices · Tonight
After
Official site Book direct$129
OTA A$129
OTA B$129
Rate parity restored

The proof did the work

We identified exactly which OTAs were breaking their contracts. With clear proof in hand, most fixed it on their own. A few got cease and desist letters. Travelers started booking direct again, without the hotels cutting rates or paying OTA commissions.

Rate parity: the rule that OTAs can't advertise a hotel cheaper than the hotel's own rate contractually.

The result

12x at the peak.

12x

peak ROAS, up from about 2.5x while rate parity was broken

0x4x8x Rate parity fixed ~2.5x 12x 1234567 Months from launch
ROAS moves month to month. 12x was the peak.

Fixing rate parity and optimizing the campaigns around it turned one marketing insight into a business decision for the whole company.

1.5+ years in. McCarter Collective sits on the C-suite as fractional CMO alongside the CEO, COO and VP.

CEO
COO
VP
Fractional CMO
"They couldn't figure out why direct bookings weren't coming in. The data gave us the answer, and that clarity is what let us scale with confidence."
Landon McCarter · Founder, McCarter Collective

What's next

The marketing works.
Now we build the system.

SEO, Google Hotel Ads, AI recommendations and social are dialed in. The next stage is an agentic AI system, including a direct booking experience connected to the hotels' own systems, built to take the group to the next level as it grows.

Done
Website rebuilt, 18 profiles aligned, Hotel Ads to 12x.
Now
Scaling marketing across locations.
Next
Agentic AI booking system, in early build.
Traveler asks AI
Hotel recommended
Books direct
Download the PDF
Free Loom review

Want a free 5-minute Loom on your Google Maps and Business Profile?

If you're interested in this part of the marketing process, I'll do a quick personal audit and send you a 5-minute Loom of what I'm seeing on your Google Business Profile. Use it to work with me, or take it and fix it yourself. Recorded by me, sent to you directly. No sales pitch.

I record a handful of these each week.
Want to talk sooner? Book a Strategy Call.

Two ways to start: talk it through, or let me look at your site first.

Book a Strategy Call Get my Google Maps Loom review